{
 "meta": {
  "id": "smart-thermostats",
  "label": "Smart thermostats",
  "type": "Products",
  "primaryAxis": "environment",
  "tradeoff": [
   "privacy",
   "accessibility"
  ],
  "tradeoffLabels": [
   "least data exposure",
   "easiest install"
  ],
  "source": "Conscious Consuming (curated)",
  "attribution": "Curated from public ENERGY STAR pages, product pages, privacy policies, security notices, smart-home compatibility docs, and independent privacy reviews. HVAC compatibility is house-specific; check wiring, voltage, C-wire, boiler type, region, rebates, and installer requirements before buying. Suggest changes via Contribute.",
  "allergens": false,
  "presets": {
   "Balanced": {
    "w": {
     "environment": 3,
     "privacy": 3,
     "openness": 2,
     "transparency": 2,
     "accessibility": 2
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Energy saver": {
    "w": {
     "environment": 5,
     "transparency": 3,
     "accessibility": 2,
     "privacy": 1,
     "openness": 1
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Privacy-first": {
    "w": {
     "privacy": 5,
     "transparency": 3,
     "openness": 2,
     "environment": 2,
     "accessibility": 1
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Open ecosystem": {
    "w": {
     "openness": 5,
     "transparency": 3,
     "privacy": 2,
     "environment": 2,
     "accessibility": 1
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Easy install": {
    "w": {
     "accessibility": 5,
     "environment": 3,
     "transparency": 2,
     "privacy": 1,
     "openness": 1
    },
    "x": []
   }
  },
  "n": 12,
  "valueSignatureProfile": {
   "entryCount": 12,
   "signedEntries": 12,
   "drawableEntries": 12,
   "minimumThemesForBloom": 2,
   "themeCounts": {
    "planet": 12,
    "honesty": 12,
    "privacy": 12,
    "cost": 12
   }
  },
  "provenanceProfile": {
   "entryCount": 12,
   "singleSourceEntries": 7,
   "multiSourceEntries": 5,
   "noSourceEntries": 0,
   "noteOnlyEntries": 0,
   "averageSourceDomains": 2.33,
   "topPrimarySources": [
    {
     "label": "amazon.com",
     "entries": 2
    },
    {
     "label": "ecobee.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "getmysa.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "helpcenter.netatmo.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "hivehome.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "honeywellhome.com",
     "entries": 1
    }
   ]
  },
  "decision": {
   "category": "smart-thermostats",
   "reads": {
    "text": "Compare smart thermostats by environmental impact, privacy, everyday access, and openness.",
    "basis": [
     {
      "criterion": "environment",
      "readsAs": "environmental impact"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "privacy",
      "readsAs": "privacy"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "accessibility",
      "readsAs": "everyday access"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "openness",
      "readsAs": "openness"
     }
    ],
    "signature": {
     "by": "Conscious Consuming",
     "on": "2026-07-15",
     "status": "approved-batch"
    },
    "receipt": {
     "dataset": "smart-thermostats",
     "entryCount": 12,
     "criteria": [
      {
       "criterion": "environment",
       "readsAs": "environmental impact",
       "known": 12,
       "minimum": 58,
       "maximum": 92,
       "spread": 34
      },
      {
       "criterion": "privacy",
       "readsAs": "privacy",
       "known": 12,
       "minimum": 34,
       "maximum": 92,
       "spread": 58
      },
      {
       "criterion": "accessibility",
       "readsAs": "everyday access",
       "known": 12,
       "minimum": 55,
       "maximum": 86,
       "spread": 31
      },
      {
       "criterion": "openness",
       "readsAs": "openness",
       "known": 12,
       "minimum": 42,
       "maximum": 88,
       "spread": 46
      }
     ]
    }
   },
   "axes": [
    {
     "id": "privacy-or-setup",
     "kind": "tradeoff",
     "label": "Privacy or setup",
     "question": "Less data exposure or easier setup?",
     "criteria": [
      "privacy",
      "accessibility"
     ],
     "poles": [
      "Less exposure",
      "Easier setup"
     ],
     "default": 50
    },
    {
     "id": "environment",
     "kind": "criterion",
     "label": "Environmental impact",
     "question": "Does lower environmental impact matter more?",
     "criteria": [
      "environment"
     ],
     "poles": [
      "Flexible",
      "Lower impact"
     ],
     "default": 50
    }
   ],
   "budget": {
    "available": false,
    "mode": "none",
    "knownEntries": 0,
    "coverage": 0
   },
   "archetypes": [
    "best-for-most",
    "strictest-match"
   ],
   "page": {
    "stage": "approved-batch",
    "primaryRoute": true
   },
   "consumer": {
    "reads": "Round 8 approved category differences reads.",
    "axes": "Round 8 practical decision dials, with the S4 cost-or-values default where evidence permits.",
    "budget": "Round 8 honest budget eligibility, with S4 refusing to guess missing cost data.",
    "archetypes": "Round 8 computed answer slots matched to available category evidence.",
    "page": "Round 7 personal precedence extended in Round 9 to the shared decision page for every live category."
   }
  }
 },
 "criteria": [
  {
   "key": "environment",
   "label": "Energy savings",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  },
  {
   "key": "privacy",
   "label": "Home data privacy",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  },
  {
   "key": "openness",
   "label": "Open ecosystem",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  },
  {
   "key": "transparency",
   "label": "Clear support & terms",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  },
  {
   "key": "accessibility",
   "label": "Install & compatibility",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  }
 ],
 "products": [
  {
   "code": "sensi-touch-2",
   "name": "Sensi Touch 2",
   "brand": "privacy-forward mainstream",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A mainstream ENERGY STAR thermostat with an unusually explicit privacy positioning and broad U.S. HVAC compatibility.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 88,
    "privacy": 92,
    "openness": 72,
    "transparency": 86,
    "accessibility": 78
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "ENERGY STAR-certified smart thermostats are independently certified from field data to deliver energy savings; Sensi models appear in the ENERGY STAR thermostat program.",
     "source": "https://www.energystar.gov/products/smart_thermostats",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Sensi's public positioning emphasizes data privacy and says Sensi does not sell personal information to third parties.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/Emerson-Thermostat-Touchscreen-Display-Certified/dp/B01N3CEUDH",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Sensi works through mainstream smart-home integrations rather than an open local-control protocol, so openness is good but not maximal.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/Emerson-Thermostat-Touchscreen-Display-Certified/dp/B01N3CEUDH",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Sensi publishes installation, compatibility, privacy, and energy-savings claims in public product materials.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/Emerson-Thermostat-Touchscreen-Display-Certified/dp/B01N3CEUDH",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "DIY installation and broad 24V HVAC support help accessibility, but a C-wire may still be required depending on the model and home.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/Emerson-Thermostat-Touchscreen-Display-Certified/dp/B01N3CEUDH",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "ENERGY STAR smart thermostats",
     "url": "https://www.energystar.gov/products/smart_thermostats"
    },
    {
     "label": "Product details",
     "url": "https://www.amazon.com/Emerson-Thermostat-Touchscreen-Display-Certified/dp/B01N3CEUDH"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Energy Star",
    "Privacy",
    "DIY-friendly"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 88,
    "honesty": 86,
    "privacy": 82,
    "cost": 78
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "amazon.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "amazon.com",
     "energystar.gov"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "ecobee-premium",
   "name": "ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium",
   "brand": "sensor-rich premium",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A strong premium option with remote sensors, broad integrations, and better-than-average privacy language for a connected-home product.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 92,
    "privacy": 78,
    "openness": 84,
    "transparency": 88,
    "accessibility": 72
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "ecobee markets its premium thermostat around smart energy savings, occupancy sensing, and utility-program participation.",
     "source": "https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/smart-thermostats/smart-thermostat-premium/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "ecobee's privacy notice states that users own their personal information and device data and can manage or delete it.",
     "source": "https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/privacy-policy/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "ecobee supports several smart-home ecosystems and voice assistants, which reduces lock-in compared with single-ecosystem thermostats.",
     "source": "https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/smart-thermostats/smart-thermostat-premium/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Mozilla's privacy review notes ecobee's comparatively strong privacy language while still warning that privacy claims need scrutiny.",
     "source": "https://www.mozillafoundation.org/en/privacynotincluded/ecobee-smart-thermostats-premium/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Premium pricing and installation complexity lower accessibility even though the product includes a power-extender kit and rich setup docs.",
     "source": "https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/smart-thermostats/smart-thermostat-premium/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product page",
     "url": "https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/smart-thermostats/smart-thermostat-premium/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Privacy",
     "url": "https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/privacy-policy/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US",
    "global"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Energy Star",
    "Privacy",
    "Smart sensors"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 92,
    "honesty": 88,
    "privacy": 81,
    "cost": 72
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "ecobee.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "ecobee.com",
     "mozillafoundation.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 1,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "tado-x",
   "name": "tado Smart Thermostat X",
   "brand": "Matter-forward EU heating",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A European smart-heating platform with Matter/Thread support and strong energy-savings claims, best for compatible EU/UK heating systems.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 86,
    "privacy": 72,
    "openness": 88,
    "transparency": 82,
    "accessibility": 62
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "tado cites a Fraunhofer Institute report finding up to 28% heating energy savings for tado smart thermostats.",
     "source": "https://www.tado.com/en/about/fraunhofer-study",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "tado's app privacy listing shows location, contact information, identifiers, usage data, and diagnostics may be handled by the app.",
     "source": "https://apps.apple.com/lv/app/tado/id574418486",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "tado X uses Matter, increasing cross-platform control across iOS, Android, Alexa, Siri, and Google Home ecosystems.",
     "source": "https://www.tado.com/en/about/matter-smart-home-devices",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "tado publishes support pages for Matter setup and links to terms and privacy policy inside its support system.",
     "source": "https://help.tado.com/en/articles/8300517-where-can-i-find-the-terms-conditions-and-the-privacy-policy",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "tado X is strong where heating-system compatibility fits, but region, bridge, radiator valve, and subscription-feature choices complicate setup.",
     "source": "https://www.tado.com/en",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Matter support",
     "url": "https://www.tado.com/en/about/matter-smart-home-devices"
    },
    {
     "label": "Energy study",
     "url": "https://www.tado.com/en/about/fraunhofer-study"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "EU",
    "UK"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Matter",
    "Open ecosystem",
    "Energy saving"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 86,
    "honesty": 82,
    "privacy": 80,
    "cost": 62
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "tado.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "tado.com",
     "apps.apple.com",
     "help.tado.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 1,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "netatmo",
   "name": "Netatmo Smart Thermostat",
   "brand": "EU privacy-leaning",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A European smart thermostat with GDPR-region privacy posture and broad assistant compatibility, strongest for compatible boiler systems.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 80,
    "privacy": 76,
    "openness": 82,
    "transparency": 78,
    "accessibility": 60
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Netatmo's energy app and thermostat materials emphasize scheduling and consumption tracking to reduce unnecessary heating.",
     "source": "https://apps.apple.com/us/app/netatmo-energy/id730893725",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Mozilla's Netatmo thermostat review highlights GDPR-region protections and notes that Netatmo says it does not sell data.",
     "source": "https://www.mozillafoundation.org/en/privacynotincluded/netatmo-smart-thermostat/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Netatmo publishes HomeKit compatibility support and supports major assistant integrations for its thermostat ecosystem.",
     "source": "https://helpcenter.netatmo.com/hc/en-us/articles/5604055429266-Is-my-product-compatible-with-Apple-Homekit",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Netatmo publishes a dedicated privacy notice for app and product data processing.",
     "source": "https://view.netatmo.com/default/legals/magellan?app_type=app_magellan&country=US&goto=privacy",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Netatmo is most accessible in compatible European heating setups; regional availability and boiler compatibility can limit fit.",
     "source": "https://helpcenter.netatmo.com/hc/en-us/sections/11724852788498-Updates",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Privacy notice",
     "url": "https://view.netatmo.com/default/legals/magellan?app_type=app_magellan&country=US&goto=privacy"
    },
    {
     "label": "Mozilla review",
     "url": "https://www.mozillafoundation.org/en/privacynotincluded/netatmo-smart-thermostat/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "EU",
    "UK"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Privacy",
    "Open ecosystem",
    "HomeKit"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 80,
    "honesty": 78,
    "privacy": 79,
    "cost": 60
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 4,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "helpcenter.netatmo.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "helpcenter.netatmo.com",
     "apps.apple.com",
     "mozillafoundation.org",
     "view.netatmo.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "google-nest-learning-4",
   "name": "Google Nest Learning Thermostat",
   "brand": "Google ecosystem",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A polished, recognizable smart thermostat with strong energy features and a major-platform privacy tradeoff.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 90,
    "privacy": 48,
    "openness": 70,
    "transparency": 82,
    "accessibility": 76
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Nest Learning Thermostats are tied to ENERGY STAR certification and Google markets the product around automatic schedules and energy-saving guidance.",
     "source": "https://www.energystar.gov/products/smart_thermostats",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Google Home and Nest privacy documentation says Nest device data is handled under Google account and Google privacy systems.",
     "source": "https://support.google.com/googlehome/answer/9415830?hl=en",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Nest supports the Google Home ecosystem and some wider integrations, but it remains heavily tied to Google's smart-home account model.",
     "source": "https://safety.google/intl/en_us/products/nest/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Google publishes Nest privacy commitments and sensor-use explanations, making the data model more inspectable than many smart-home products.",
     "source": "https://safety.google/intl/en_us/products/nest/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Nest is widely available and user-friendly, but HVAC compatibility and Google-account dependence should be checked before purchase.",
     "source": "https://support.google.com/googlehome/?hl=en",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Nest privacy hub",
     "url": "https://support.google.com/googlehome/answer/9415830?hl=en"
    },
    {
     "label": "Nest privacy commitments",
     "url": "https://safety.google/intl/en_us/products/nest/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US",
    "UK",
    "EU"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Energy Star",
    "Mainstream",
    "Honest floor"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 90,
    "honesty": 82,
    "privacy": 59,
    "cost": 76
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "safety.google",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "safety.google",
     "support.google.com",
     "energystar.gov"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "honeywell-home-t9",
   "name": "Honeywell Home T9",
   "brand": "multi-room mainstream",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A familiar room-sensor thermostat with ENERGY STAR certification and broad assistant support, but Resideo account/app dependence.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 86,
    "privacy": 60,
    "openness": 72,
    "transparency": 78,
    "accessibility": 74
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "ENERGY STAR lists Honeywell Home T9 thermostat families as certified connected thermostats with demand-response capability.",
     "source": "https://www.energystar.gov/productfinder/product/certified-connected-thermostats/details/2333888",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Resideo's connected-home EULA and privacy statement describe personal data, cookie, service, and product-data processing.",
     "source": "https://www.resideo.com/us/en/corporate/legal/eula/en-us/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Honeywell Home T9 supports Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple HomeKit, and the Resideo app, reducing single-assistant lock-in.",
     "source": "https://www.honeywellhome.com/products/t9-smart-thermostat",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Honeywell Home publishes T9 product, compatibility, sensor, and ENERGY STAR information on public pages.",
     "source": "https://www.honeywellhome.com/products/t9-smart-thermostat",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "T9 supports common central HVAC systems and room sensors, but compatibility and C-wire/power-adapter needs should be checked.",
     "source": "https://www.honeywellhome.com/products/t9-smart-thermostat",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product page",
     "url": "https://www.honeywellhome.com/products/t9-smart-thermostat"
    },
    {
     "label": "ENERGY STAR listing",
     "url": "https://www.energystar.gov/productfinder/product/certified-connected-thermostats/details/2333888"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Energy Star",
    "Smart sensors",
    "Mainstream"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 86,
    "honesty": 78,
    "privacy": 66,
    "cost": 74
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "honeywellhome.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "honeywellhome.com",
     "energystar.gov",
     "resideo.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "drayton-wiser",
   "name": "Drayton Wiser",
   "brand": "UK heating system",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A UK smart-heating platform with strong multi-room and OpenTherm support, useful for boiler homes that want more local heating control.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 82,
    "privacy": 66,
    "openness": 76,
    "transparency": 80,
    "accessibility": 66
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Drayton Wiser cites energy-saving potential from direct boiler modulation, smart control, room-by-room control, and smart modes.",
     "source": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/pages/save-money-and-energy-with-a-smart-thermostat",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Drayton Wiser publishes a privacy policy and data-protection guidance for smart heating controls.",
     "source": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/pages/privacy",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Wiser supports Alexa, Google Assistant, IFTTT, and OpenTherm in supported boiler setups.",
     "source": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/products/thermostat-kit-1",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Drayton Wiser publishes a security support policy naming support periods and security-reporting channels.",
     "source": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/pages/security-support-policy",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Wiser is strong for compatible UK boiler systems, but kit selection, hub, TRVs, and installation needs make setup less universal.",
     "source": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product page",
     "url": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/products/thermostat-kit-1"
    },
    {
     "label": "Security policy",
     "url": "https://wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk/pages/security-support-policy"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "UK"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "OpenTherm",
    "Security support",
    "Energy saving"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 82,
    "honesty": 80,
    "privacy": 71,
    "cost": 66
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "wiser.draytoncontrols.co.uk",
    "independentSourceCount": 0,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "mysa",
   "name": "Mysa Smart Thermostat",
   "brand": "line-voltage specialist",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A specialty smart thermostat for electric baseboard, fan-forced, in-floor, mini-split, and other nonstandard electric heating/cooling setups.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 78,
    "privacy": 64,
    "openness": 78,
    "transparency": 76,
    "accessibility": 58
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Mysa markets smart scheduling, geofencing, utility demand response, and no-subscription control for electric heating and cooling.",
     "source": "https://getmysa.com/en-us",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Apple's app privacy label for Mysa lists location, contact, identifiers, and usage data among handled data types.",
     "source": "https://apps.apple.com/ca/app/mysa/id1250453565",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Mysa states support for Google Home, Amazon Alexa, and Apple HomeKit.",
     "source": "https://getmysa.com/en-us",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Mysa publishes product-family and support documentation by heating/cooling type, which helps avoid buying the wrong voltage class.",
     "source": "https://help.getmysa.com/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Mysa is unusually useful for line-voltage and mini-split situations, but that specialization means it is not a drop-in fit for ordinary central HVAC.",
     "source": "https://help.getmysa.com/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product families",
     "url": "https://getmysa.com/en-us"
    },
    {
     "label": "Support",
     "url": "https://help.getmysa.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Line voltage",
    "No subscription",
    "Open ecosystem"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 78,
    "honesty": 76,
    "privacy": 71,
    "cost": 58
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "getmysa.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "getmysa.com",
     "help.getmysa.com",
     "apps.apple.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 1,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "sinope",
   "name": "Sinope Smart Thermostat",
   "brand": "Canada line-voltage",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A Canadian smart thermostat specialist for electric baseboard and other line-voltage heating, strongest when that niche matches the home.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 80,
    "privacy": 68,
    "openness": 72,
    "transparency": 76,
    "accessibility": 55
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Sinope says its baseboard thermostat uses schedules, geofencing, TRIAC control, and time-of-use features to reduce unnecessary electric heating.",
     "source": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/products/smart-thermostat-electric-baseboard",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Sinope publishes privacy and service links on its storefront, but detailed app-data disclosures are less prominent than some competitors.",
     "source": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/policies/privacy-policy",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Sinope product pages show SmartThings and Hilo support and describe ecosystem integrations for the thermostat.",
     "source": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/products/smart-thermostat-electric-baseboard",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Sinope publishes product specifications and compatibility details for electric baseboard thermostats.",
     "source": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/products/smart-thermostat-electric-baseboard",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Sinope is helpful for electric-baseboard homes, but line-voltage compatibility makes it unsuitable for ordinary low-voltage central HVAC.",
     "source": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/products/smart-thermostat-electric-baseboard",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Baseboard thermostat",
     "url": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/products/smart-thermostat-electric-baseboard"
    },
    {
     "label": "Privacy",
     "url": "https://www.sinopetech.com/en/policies/privacy-policy"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Line voltage",
    "SmartThings",
    "Local"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 80,
    "honesty": 76,
    "privacy": 70,
    "cost": 55
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "sinopetech.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 0,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "amazon-smart-thermostat",
   "name": "Amazon Smart Thermostat",
   "brand": "Alexa budget",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A cheap ENERGY STAR thermostat for Alexa households, with good affordability and a weak privacy/open-ecosystem fit.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 84,
    "privacy": 34,
    "openness": 42,
    "transparency": 72,
    "accessibility": 86
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "The ENERGY STAR product finder lists Amazon Smart Thermostat models as certified connected thermostats with demand-response capability.",
     "source": "https://www.energystar.gov/productfinder/product/certified-connected-thermostats/details/2515784",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Mozilla's privacy review highlights Alexa ecosystem dependence and privacy concerns around Amazon smart-home data.",
     "source": "https://www.mozillafoundation.org/en/privacynotincluded/amazon-smart-thermostat/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Amazon's thermostat is built around Alexa control and requires the Alexa app, making it a weak fit for open-ecosystem values.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-Smart-Thermostat/dp/B08J4C8871",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Amazon publishes product, setup, and support materials, but the wider Alexa privacy model is harder to evaluate from a thermostat page alone.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=GMCQK6C7JTCG6NCA",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Low price, ENERGY STAR certification, and DIY setup make this one of the most accessible options for compatible 24V HVAC systems.",
     "source": "https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-Smart-Thermostat/dp/B08J4C8871",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product page",
     "url": "https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-Smart-Thermostat/dp/B08J4C8871"
    },
    {
     "label": "Mozilla review",
     "url": "https://www.mozillafoundation.org/en/privacynotincluded/amazon-smart-thermostat/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Energy Star",
    "Low cost",
    "Honest floor"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 84,
    "honesty": 72,
    "privacy": 38,
    "cost": 86
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "amazon.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "amazon.com",
     "energystar.gov",
     "mozillafoundation.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "hive-thermostat-mini",
   "name": "Hive Thermostat Mini",
   "brand": "UK mainstream",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A UK smart-heating option from Centrica/Hive with a low device price, optional service layers, and a mainstream-platform privacy tradeoff.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 74,
    "privacy": 52,
    "openness": 52,
    "transparency": 70,
    "accessibility": 72
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Hive markets the Thermostat Mini around heating-bill and carbon savings, including app control and smart scheduling.",
     "source": "https://www.hivehome.com/shop/smart-heating/hive-thermostat-mini",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Hive's privacy policy explains how Centrica Hive collects, shares, and uses personal data for Hive services.",
     "source": "https://www.hivehome.com/privacy",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Hive works with Alexa and Google Assistant, but it is primarily a Hive/Centrica hub-and-app ecosystem rather than an open local-control system.",
     "source": "https://www.hivehome.com/blog/smart-heating/a-simple-guide-to-smart-thermostats",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Hive publishes product pricing, installation, Hive+ renewal notes, and privacy policy pages for customers to inspect.",
     "source": "https://www.hivehome.com/shop/smart-heating/hive-thermostat-mini",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "The Mini's low purchase price and UK installer path help accessibility, but hub, pro-install, and optional subscription layers add complexity.",
     "source": "https://www.hivehome.com/shop/smart-heating/hive-thermostat-mini",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product page",
     "url": "https://www.hivehome.com/shop/smart-heating/hive-thermostat-mini"
    },
    {
     "label": "Privacy",
     "url": "https://www.hivehome.com/privacy"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "UK"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Low cost",
    "Mainstream",
    "Honest floor"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 74,
    "honesty": 70,
    "privacy": 52,
    "cost": 72
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "hivehome.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 0,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "wyze-thermostat",
   "name": "Wyze Thermostat",
   "brand": "budget smart-home",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": true,
   "description": "A low-cost thermostat for Wyze smart-home users, but weaker on energy-certification confidence and privacy/open-ecosystem values.",
   "scores": {
    "environment": 58,
    "privacy": 38,
    "openness": 42,
    "transparency": 62,
    "accessibility": 84
   },
   "provenance": {
    "environment": {
     "note": "Wyze's support page says Wyze Thermostat is not ENERGY STAR approved yet, lowering confidence in verified savings.",
     "source": "https://support.wyze.com/hc/en-us/articles/360049980951-Is-Wyze-Thermostat-ENERGY-STAR-approved",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "privacy": {
     "note": "Wyze's privacy statement covers account, device, usage, app, and service data across the Wyze smart-home ecosystem.",
     "source": "https://www.wyze.com/pages/privacy-statement",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "openness": {
     "note": "Wyze Thermostat is primarily built for the Wyze app ecosystem plus mainstream assistants, not open local control.",
     "source": "https://www.wyze.com/products/wyze-thermostat",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Wyze publishes product and support pages, including a direct answer about lack of ENERGY STAR approval.",
     "source": "https://support.wyze.com/hc/en-us/articles/360049980951-Is-Wyze-Thermostat-ENERGY-STAR-approved",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Low price and consumer-friendly setup help accessibility for compatible systems, but privacy and certification tradeoffs remain.",
     "source": "https://www.wyze.com/products/wyze-thermostat",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Product page",
     "url": "https://www.wyze.com/products/wyze-thermostat"
    },
    {
     "label": "ENERGY STAR status",
     "url": "https://support.wyze.com/hc/en-us/articles/360049980951-Is-Wyze-Thermostat-ENERGY-STAR-approved"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Low cost",
    "Mainstream",
    "Honest floor"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "planet": 58,
    "honesty": 62,
    "privacy": 40,
    "cost": 84
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 5,
    "sourcedFactCount": 5,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "wyze.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "wyze.com",
     "support.wyze.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 0,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  }
 ]
}