{
 "meta": {
  "id": "protein-and-sports-nutrition",
  "label": "Protein and sports nutrition",
  "type": "Products",
  "primaryAxis": "safety",
  "tradeoff": [
   "economical",
   "safety"
  ],
  "tradeoffLabels": [
   "cheapest per 25 g of protein",
   "least lead in Consumer Reports' test"
  ],
  "source": "Conscious Consuming",
  "attribution": "Covers protein powders and ready-to-drink protein shakes sold in the US, with plain Greek yogurt as the food route that needs no supplement. The roster follows the products Consumer Reports tested, so common brands CR did not test, such as Dymatize ISO100, Isopure, Ghost and MyProtein, are not scored here, and the mass gainers, Ensure, Jocko Mölk and the discontinued Momentous products CR tested are left out. Safety scores come from Consumer Reports' October 2025 laboratory test of 23 protein products and its follow-up test of five more. CR bought two to four lots of each anonymously between November 2024 and January 2025 and measured arsenic, cadmium and lead. The score falls in a straight line from 100 for no lead detected to 0 at 200 percent of CR's level of concern for one serving. That level is 0.5 micrograms of lead a day, the California Proposition 65 maximum allowable dose level. It is stricter than the 8.8 micrograms a day that FDA uses as an interim reference level for women of childbearing age and told CR it considers sufficient to apply to all adults. CR states that no federal limit for lead in protein powder exists and that its findings cannot be read as a Prop 65 compliance finding. Consumer Reports describes itself as an independent, nonprofit member organization. The recall score reads FDA's enforcement reports through the openFDA interface, searched on 29 September 2026 for each brand name in the product description and recalling firm fields. It scores the same format under the brand, so a shake recall does not lower a powder's score. Records run from 2012, and a text search can miss a record filed under another product name, so each brand with no record at all is searched in one query that also includes Orgain as a control, which lets a reader see that the search returned something. A brand with no record scores 85, one with only Class II or III records scores 60, one with a Class I record older than five years scores 45, and one with a Class I record inside five years scores 20. FDA defines Class I as a reasonable probability of serious adverse health consequences or death. The certification score records only whether a product is in the NSF Certified for Sport register, which NSF says verifies that products contain none of 290 banned substances, that the label matches the contents, that contaminants are not at unsafe levels and that the factory is audited. A product missing from that register is left unscored, because the registers of Informed Sport and Informed Choice, the other main programmes, could not be read for this decision, so absence from NSF does not show a product is untested. Price is per 25 grams of protein at one listed size on one page and date, mostly Target, and it moves between retailers and weeks. Not medical advice. CR's article and its experts state that most adults can meet their protein needs from food, and a doctor or dietitian can advise on individual needs. Reviewed 2026-09. Suggest changes via Contribute.",
  "allergens": false,
  "presets": {
   "Balanced": {
    "w": {
     "economical": 3,
     "safety": 3,
     "health": 2,
     "certification": 2
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Cheapest": {
    "w": {
     "economical": 5,
     "safety": 2,
     "health": 2,
     "certification": 1
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Least lead": {
    "w": {
     "safety": 5,
     "health": 2,
     "certification": 2,
     "economical": 2
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Tested for sport": {
    "w": {
     "certification": 5,
     "safety": 3,
     "health": 2,
     "economical": 2
    },
    "x": []
   }
  },
  "n": 22,
  "valueSignatureProfile": {
   "entryCount": 22,
   "signedEntries": 22,
   "drawableEntries": 16,
   "minimumThemesForBloom": 2,
   "themeCounts": {
    "health": 21,
    "honesty": 5,
    "cost": 15
   }
  },
  "provenanceProfile": {
   "entryCount": 22,
   "singleSourceEntries": 1,
   "multiSourceEntries": 21,
   "noSourceEntries": 0,
   "noteOnlyEntries": 0,
   "averageSourceDomains": 2.68,
   "topPrimarySources": [
    {
     "label": "api.fda.gov",
     "entries": 21
    },
    {
     "label": "target.com",
     "entries": 1
    }
   ]
  },
  "decision": {
   "category": "protein-and-sports-nutrition",
   "reads": {
    "text": "Compare protein and sports nutrition by safety, cost, and body safety.",
    "basis": [
     {
      "criterion": "safety",
      "readsAs": "safety"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "economical",
      "readsAs": "cost"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "health",
      "readsAs": "body safety"
     }
    ],
    "signature": {
     "by": "Conscious Consuming",
     "on": "2026-07-15",
     "status": "approved-batch"
    },
    "receipt": {
     "dataset": "protein-and-sports-nutrition",
     "entryCount": 22,
     "criteria": [
      {
       "criterion": "safety",
       "readsAs": "safety",
       "known": 18,
       "minimum": 0,
       "maximum": 79,
       "spread": 79
      },
      {
       "criterion": "economical",
       "readsAs": "cost",
       "known": 15,
       "minimum": 0,
       "maximum": 88,
       "spread": 88
      },
      {
       "criterion": "health",
       "readsAs": "body safety",
       "known": 21,
       "minimum": 20,
       "maximum": 85,
       "spread": 65
      }
     ]
    }
   },
   "axes": [
    {
     "id": "cost-or-values",
     "kind": "cost-values",
     "label": "Cost or overall fit",
     "question": "Lower cost or a stronger overall fit?",
     "criteria": [
      "economical",
      "safety",
      "health"
     ],
     "poles": [
      "Lower cost",
      "Stronger overall fit"
     ],
     "default": 50
    },
    {
     "id": "health",
     "kind": "criterion",
     "label": "Body safety",
     "question": "Does body safety matter more?",
     "criteria": [
      "health"
     ],
     "poles": [
      "Flexible",
      "Body safety"
     ],
     "default": 50
    }
   ],
   "budget": {
    "available": true,
    "mode": "assessed-affordability-rank",
    "criterion": "economical",
    "minimumKnown": 5,
    "knownEntries": 15,
    "coverage": 0.6818
   },
   "archetypes": [
    "best-for-most",
    "strictest-match",
    "budget-honest"
   ],
   "page": {
    "stage": "approved-batch",
    "primaryRoute": true
   },
   "consumer": {
    "reads": "Round 8 approved category differences reads.",
    "axes": "Round 8 practical decision dials, with the S4 cost-or-values default where evidence permits.",
    "budget": "Round 8 honest budget eligibility, with S4 refusing to guess missing cost data.",
    "archetypes": "Round 8 computed answer slots matched to available category evidence.",
    "page": "Round 7 personal precedence extended in Round 9 to the shared decision page for every live category."
   }
  }
 },
 "criteria": [
  {
   "key": "economical",
   "label": "Price per 25 g of protein (US retail, one listed size and date)",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "measured"
  },
  {
   "key": "safety",
   "label": "Lead per serving in Consumer Reports' 2025 lab test (lower is better)",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "measured"
  },
  {
   "key": "health",
   "label": "FDA recall record for this product format under the brand name",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "measured"
  },
  {
   "key": "certification",
   "label": "Listed in NSF's Certified for Sport register",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "certified"
  }
 ],
 "products": [
  {
   "code": "optimum-nutrition-gold-standard-whey",
   "name": "Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey (powder)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 60,
    "safety": 72,
    "health": 85,
    "certification": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Powder, Double Rich Chocolate, 22 servings (23.59 oz), at $39.99, with 24 g of protein per serving, which is about $1.89 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/optimum-nutrition-gold-standard-100-whey-protein-powder-double-rich-chocolate-24oz/-/A-78807252",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey (chocolate, one 30.5 g scoop) found lead at 56 percent of CR's level of concern per serving. CR lists it under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 1¾ servings a day.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA's enforcement reports, searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026 for the brand name, hold two Class I records for Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, both dated 7 September 2022, and both for 11 fl oz ready-to-drink shakes made by Lyons Magnus. No record for the powder was found, so the powder scores 85; the shake has its own row.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Optimum+Nutrition\"+recalling_firm:\"Optimum+Nutrition\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "certification": {
     "note": "NSF's Certified for Sport register lists Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Double Rich Chocolate (4.53 kg package, 24 g protein per 30.4 g scoop) and a Vanilla Ice Cream listing in a 4.62 kg package. NSF says the programme verifies that products hold none of 290 banned substances, that the label matches the contents and that contaminants are not at unsafe levels. The register lists the 10 lb sizes, and the 23.59 oz tub priced on this row is not itself shown on the pages read, searched 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1256427",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/optimum-nutrition-gold-standard-100-whey-protein-powder-double-rich-chocolate-24oz/-/A-78807252"
    },
    {
     "label": "NSF Certified for Sport listing",
     "url": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1256427"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Optimum Nutrition",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Optimum+Nutrition\"+recalling_firm:\"Optimum+Nutrition\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey",
    "Powder",
    "NSF Certified for Sport"
   ],
   "description": "The best-known whey powder in the US, listed on NSF's register and under Consumer Reports' daily limit for lead, at a middling price per 25 g of protein.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 78.5,
    "honesty": 85,
    "cost": 60
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 4,
    "sourcedFactCount": 4,
    "sourceDomainCount": 4,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "nsfsport.com",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 4
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "optimum-nutrition-gold-standard-shake",
   "name": "Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein Shake (ready to drink)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "safety": 25,
    "health": 20
   },
   "provenance": {
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Protein Shake (chocolate, one 325 ml carton) found lead at 150 percent of CR's level of concern per serving. CR lists it under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 4⅔ servings a week.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA enforcement reports F-1661-2022 and F-1662-2022, dated 7 September 2022, classify the recall of Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey vanilla and chocolate 11 fl oz shakes, made for Optimum Nutrition by Lyons Magnus, as Class I, for findings and potential for Cronobacter sakazakii and Clostridium botulinum. FDA defines Class I as a reasonable probability of serious adverse health consequences or death. Both records show a status of Terminated.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Optimum+Nutrition\"+recalling_firm:\"Optimum+Nutrition\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Optimum Nutrition",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Optimum+Nutrition\"+recalling_firm:\"Optimum+Nutrition\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey",
    "Ready to drink",
    "Class I recall 2022"
   ],
   "description": "The ready-to-drink shake from the same brand as the powder, which carries a 2022 Class I recall record and a higher lead result than the powder in Consumer Reports' test. No price was read for it.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 22.5
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "bsn-syntha-6",
   "name": "BSN Syntha-6 (powder)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 63,
    "safety": 77,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists BSN Syntha-6 Whey Protein Powder with Micellar Casein and Milk Protein Isolate, Chocolate Milkshake, 48 servings, at $75.99, with 22 g of protein per 47 g scoop, which is about $1.80 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/bsn-syntha-6-whey-protein-powder-with-micellar-casein-milk-protein-isolate-chocolate-milkshake-48-servings-packaging-may-vary/-/A-1006339846",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of BSN Syntha-6 Protein Powder (vanilla ice cream, one 47 g scoop) found lead at 46 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 2 servings a day. BSN did not respond to CR's request for comment.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Syntha and BSN found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/bsn-syntha-6-whey-protein-powder-with-micellar-casein-milk-protein-isolate-chocolate-milkshake-48-servings-packaging-may-vary/-/A-1006339846"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey and casein",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "A whey and casein blend sold at mass retail, with a low lead result in Consumer Reports' test and no FDA recall record found.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 81,
    "cost": 63
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "premier-protein-whey-powder",
   "name": "Premier Protein 100% Whey Protein Powder",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 72,
    "safety": 62,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Premier Protein 100% Whey Protein Powder, Chocolate Milkshake, 17 servings, at $29.99, with 30 g of protein per 41 g serving, which is about $1.47 per 25 g of protein, the lowest of the powders priced here.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/premier-protein-100-whey-protein-powder-chocolate-milkshake-17-serve/-/A-53106191",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' follow-up test of five reader-requested powders found Premier Protein Protein Powder (chocolate milkshake, 41 g, two scoops) at 0.38 micrograms of lead per serving, 77 percent of CR's level of concern, under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 1⅓ servings a day. Premier Protein declined to comment.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA's enforcement reports, searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026 for the brand name, hold three Class I records dated 7 September 2022 and two Class II records from 2023, all for ready-to-drink Premier Protein shakes made by contract packers. No record for the powder was found, so the powder scores 85; the shake has its own row.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Premier+Protein\"+recalling_firm:\"Premier+Protein\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports follow-up test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/premier-protein-100-whey-protein-powder-chocolate-milkshake-17-serve/-/A-53106191"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Premier Protein",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Premier+Protein\"+recalling_firm:\"Premier+Protein\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "The powder from the best-selling shake brand, the cheapest powder priced here per 25 g of protein and under CR's daily limit for lead.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 73.5,
    "cost": 72
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "premier-protein-shake",
   "name": "Premier Protein 30g Protein Shake (ready to drink)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 51,
    "health": 20
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Premier Protein Nutritional Shake, Chocolate, 11.5 fl oz, 12 pack, at $31.99, with 30 g of protein per shake, which is about $2.22 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/premier-protein-30g-protein-shake-chocolate-11-5-fl-oz-12pk/-/A-88167003",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA enforcement reports F-1623-2022, F-1624-2022 and F-1625-2022, dated 7 September 2022, classify the recall of Premier Protein chocolate, vanilla and cafe latte 11 fl oz shakes made by Lyons Magnus as Class I, for findings and potential for Cronobacter sakazakii and Clostridium botulinum. F-0337-2023 and F-0382-2023 add two Class II records for a Winter Mint Chocolate shake made by Niagara Bottling that missed pre-kill processing specifications.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Premier+Protein\"+recalling_firm:\"Premier+Protein\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/premier-protein-30g-protein-shake-chocolate-11-5-fl-oz-12pk/-/A-88167003"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Premier Protein",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Premier+Protein\"+recalling_firm:\"Premier+Protein\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Milk protein",
    "Ready to drink",
    "Class I recall 2022"
   ],
   "description": "The ready-to-drink shake behind the brand's popularity, with a Class I FDA record from 2022. Consumer Reports did not test this format.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 20,
    "cost": 51
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "equate-whey-protein-powder",
   "name": "Equate Whey Protein Powder (Walmart)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "safety": 72,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' follow-up test found Walmart's Equate Whey Protein Powder (rich chocolate, one 30.4 g scoop) at 0.27 micrograms of lead per serving, 55 percent of CR's level of concern, under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 1¾ servings a day. Walmart did not respond to CR's requests for comment.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA's enforcement reports hold one Equate protein record, F-1907-2018, Class II, dated 5 September 2018, for an Equate High Performance Protein Shake made by California Natural Products, recalled in two lots after reports of off odor and off taste. No record for the powder was found, so the powder scores 85. Searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Equate\"+recalling_firm:\"Equate\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports follow-up test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Equate",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Equate\"+recalling_firm:\"Equate\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Store brand",
    "Whey",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "Walmart's own whey powder, low in Consumer Reports' lead test. No price page could be read for it, because Walmart's site refused automated requests.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 78.5
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "clean-simple-eats-whey-isolate",
   "name": "Clean Simple Eats Protein Powder (whey isolate)",
   "brand": "direct-to-consumer brand, whey isolate powder",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 25,
    "safety": 79,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Clean Simple Eats Protein Powder, Chocolate Brownie Batter, 19 oz, 20 servings, at $49.99, with 20 g of whey isolate protein per serving, which is about $3.12 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/clean-simple-eats-protein-powder-chocolate-brownie-batter-19oz-20-servings-whey-protein-isolate-20g-protein/-/A-94935936",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' follow-up test found Clean Simple Eats Protein Powder (chocolate brownie batter, one 34 g scoop) at 0.21 micrograms of lead per serving, 42 percent of CR's level of concern and the lowest of the five powders in that test, under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 2⅓ servings a day. Clean Simple Eats did not respond to CR's requests for comment.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Clean Simple Eats found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports follow-up test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/clean-simple-eats-protein-powder-chocolate-brownie-batter-19oz-20-servings-whey-protein-isolate-20g-protein/-/A-94935936"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey isolate",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "A whey isolate with the lowest lead result of the five powders in Consumer Reports' follow-up test, at one of the higher prices per 25 g of protein.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 82,
    "cost": 25
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "truvani-plant-protein",
   "name": "Truvani Plant-Based Protein Powder",
   "brand": "direct-to-consumer brand, pea protein powder",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 44,
    "safety": 53,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Truvani Organic Plant Based Vegan Protein Powder, Chocolate, 10 servings, at $19.79, with 20 g of protein per 33 g serving, which is about $2.47 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/truvani-organic-plant-based-vegan-protein-powder-chocolate-11-82oz-10-servings/-/A-92988632",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' follow-up test found Truvani Plant-Based Protein (chocolate, one 33 g scoop) at 0.46 micrograms of lead per serving, 93 percent of CR's level of concern and the lowest of the plant-based powders CR tested, under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 1 serving a day. Truvani's co-founder told CR the company tests every lot for heavy metals.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Truvani found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports follow-up test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/truvani-organic-plant-based-vegan-protein-powder-chocolate-11-82oz-10-servings/-/A-92988632"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Pea protein",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "The plant-based powder with the lowest lead result in Consumer Reports' tests, at a higher price per 25 g of protein than most whey.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 69,
    "cost": 44
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "ritual-essential-protein",
   "name": "Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake",
   "brand": "direct-to-consumer brand, pea protein powder",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 0,
    "safety": 46,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "ritual.com lists Essential Protein Daily Shake at $50.00 for a single purchase plus $10.99 shipping, or $35.20 on subscription shown as a sale from $44.00, for 15 servings with 20 g of protein each. The single-purchase price is about $4.17 per 25 g of protein before shipping, and the subscription sale price is about $2.93. The same page shows a lot certificate for arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury, and a California Proposition 65 warning about lead.",
     "source": "https://ritual.com/products/essential-protein-daily-shake-18",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' follow-up test found Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake (chocolate, one 33 g serving) at 0.53 micrograms of lead per serving, 107 percent of CR's level of concern, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 6½ servings a week. Ritual told CR it tests every lot for heavy metals and publishes results for one recent lot of each flavor.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Ritual found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports follow-up test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/these-five-protein-powders-had-low-lead-levels-a1151050701/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Ritual product page",
     "url": "https://ritual.com/products/essential-protein-daily-shake-18"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Pea protein",
    "Subscription"
   ],
   "description": "A pea protein powder sold direct, with a lot-level lab certificate on its page and the highest price per 25 g of protein in the roster when bought once.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 65.5,
    "cost": 0
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "ritual.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "orgain-organic-plant-protein",
   "name": "Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 46,
    "safety": 29,
    "health": 20
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Orgain Organic Vegan Plant Based Protein Powder, Vanilla Bean, 16.32 oz, at $19.99, about 10 servings of 46 g with 21 g of protein each, which is about $2.38 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/orgain-organic-vegan-plant-based-protein-powder-vanilla-bean-16-32oz/-/A-50041960",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder (vanilla bean, 46 g, two scoops) found lead at 143 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 4¾ servings a week. Orgain told CR its products are safe for daily use and that it follows FDA, EPA, WHO and EFSA guidance.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA enforcement report F-0302-2024 (report date 1 November 2023) classifies as Class I the recall of Orgain Organic Protein & 50 Superfoods Protein Powder with Probiotic, chocolate, for undeclared sesame, and F-0386-2025 (22 January 2025) classifies as Class I the recall of Orgain 30g Plant Protein Complete Protein Powder, chocolate, for potential undeclared peanut. Two 2022 Class II records for a third party's oats and protein bites name Orgain as an ingredient and are not counted. Searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/orgain-organic-vegan-plant-based-protein-powder-vanilla-bean-16-32oz/-/A-50041960"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Orgain",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Pea protein",
    "Two Class I recalls 2023 and 2025"
   ],
   "description": "A widely stocked plant-based powder with two Class I allergen recalls in FDA's records since late 2023 and a lead result above CR's level of concern.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 24.5,
    "cost": 46
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "plantfusion-complete-protein",
   "name": "PlantFusion Complete Protein",
   "brand": "independent brand, plant protein powder",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 50,
    "safety": 30,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists PlantFusion Complete Protein Powder, Creamy Vanilla Bean, 2 lb, at $56.99, 30 servings of 30 g with 21 g of protein each, which is about $2.26 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/plantfusion-complete-protein-powder-creamy-vanilla-bean-2-lb-900-g-powder/-/A-81516350",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of PlantFusion Complete Protein (creamy vanilla bean, one 30 g scoop) found lead at 140 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 5 servings a week. PlantFusion responded to CR only after publication.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for PlantFusion found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/plantfusion-complete-protein-powder-creamy-vanilla-bean-2-lb-900-g-powder/-/A-81516350"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "A plant blend priced in the middle of the roster, with a lead result above CR's level of concern and no FDA recall record found.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 57.5,
    "cost": 50
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "vega-sport-premium-protein",
   "name": "Vega Sport Premium Protein (now Vega Protein + Recovery)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 62,
    "safety": 7,
    "health": 60,
    "certification": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Vega Plant-Based Protein, Performance Protein + Recovery, Creamy Chocolate, 4 lb 5.9 oz, at $97.99, about 45 servings of 44 g with 30 g of protein each, which is about $1.81 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/vega-sport-plant-based-premium-protein-chocolate-4-lb-5-9-oz-1-98-kg/-/A-1002425180",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Vega Premium Sport Plant-Based Protein (chocolate, one 44 g scoop) found lead at 185 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 3¾ servings a week, and enough cadmium that one serving is just over CR's 4.1 microgram level. Vega told CR the product was renamed Vega Protein + Recovery and that its pea protein is now sourced from North America, so the result may not describe the current formula.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA enforcement reports F-1140-2014 and F-1141-2014 (1 January 2014) classify as Class II the recall of nine lots of Vega Sport Performance Protein chocolate and vanilla powders by Sequel Naturals for trace chloramphenicol. Five Class I records from 26 June 2013 concern bars whose chocolate coating carried undeclared milk and are not counted for a powder. No later record was found. Searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Sequel+Naturals\"+recalling_firm:\"Sequel+Naturals\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "certification": {
     "note": "NSF's Certified for Sport register lists Vega Sport Premium Protein in chocolate (44 g scoop with 30 g of protein, package sizes 44 g, 528 g and 837 g) and a Vega Performance Protein + Recovery chocolate listing. The 1.98 kg tub priced on this row is not among the chocolate package sizes shown. Searched 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1610759",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/vega-sport-plant-based-premium-protein-chocolate-4-lb-5-9-oz-1-98-kg/-/A-1002425180"
    },
    {
     "label": "NSF Certified for Sport listing",
     "url": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1610759"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Sequel Naturals (Vega)",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Sequel+Naturals\"+recalling_firm:\"Sequel+Naturals\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Powder",
    "NSF Certified for Sport"
   ],
   "description": "A plant-based sport powder on NSF's register whose Consumer Reports lead result was high, with the maker saying the formula has since changed.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 33.5,
    "honesty": 85,
    "cost": 62
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 4,
    "sourcedFactCount": 4,
    "sourceDomainCount": 4,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "nsfsport.com",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 4
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "garden-of-life-sport-plant-protein",
   "name": "Garden of Life Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "safety": 0,
    "health": 45,
    "certification": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Garden of Life Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein (vanilla, 45 g, two scoops) found lead at 564 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, at 61 parts per billion, in its Recommend Limiting to Once a Week group. Garden of Life US told CR the product is safe for daily use and that its limits follow FDA, EPA, WHO and EFSA guidance.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA enforcement reports dated 18 May 2016 classify as Class I the recall of four Garden of Life Raw Meal organic shake and meal-replacement powders for possible Salmonella contamination, covering 422,923 bottles and units. Later records cover capsule supplements (2023, Class II, undeclared soy) and an infant probiotic (2017, Class I) and are not counted for a powder. Searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Garden+of+Life\"+recalling_firm:\"Garden+of+Life\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "certification": {
     "note": "NSF's Certified for Sport register lists Garden of Life Organic Plant-Based Performance Protein in vanilla, chocolate and strawberry. The label filed with NSF for the vanilla listing shows 19 servings, a 45 g serving of two scoops with 30 g of protein and a pea, sprouted bean, lentil, garbanzo and cranberry seed blend, which matches the 45 g serving of the Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein tested by CR, although the names differ. Searched 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1233901",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "NSF Certified for Sport listing",
     "url": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1233901"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Garden of Life",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Garden+of+Life\"+recalling_firm:\"Garden+of+Life\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Powder",
    "NSF Certified for Sport"
   ],
   "description": "A plant powder listed on NSF's register that also had one of the four highest lead results in Consumer Reports' test. No price page could be read for it.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 22.5,
    "honesty": 85
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "nsfsport.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "huel-black-edition",
   "name": "Huel Black Edition",
   "brand": "direct-to-consumer brand, plant-based meal powder",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 51,
    "safety": 0,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "huel.com lists Black Edition at $60 for a single purchase or $45 on subscription, for a bag of 17 meals with 40 g of protein each, which is about $2.21 per 25 g of protein on a single purchase and $1.65 on subscription.",
     "source": "https://huel.com/products/huel-black-edition",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Huel Black Edition (chocolate, 90 g, two scoops) found 6.3 micrograms of lead per serving, about 1,290 percent of CR's level of concern, and 9.2 micrograms of cadmium, more than double the 4.1 microgram level CR uses. CR places it in Products to Avoid. Huel did not answer CR's questions about the cadmium.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Huel found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Huel product page",
     "url": "https://huel.com/products/huel-black-edition"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Meal replacement",
    "Subscription"
   ],
   "description": "A meal-replacement powder with 40 g of protein a serving and one of the two highest lead results in Consumer Reports' test.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 42.5,
    "cost": 51
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "huel.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "muscle-milk-pro-advanced-shake",
   "name": "Muscle Milk Pro Advanced Nutrition Protein Shake (ready to drink)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "safety": 36,
    "health": 60
   },
   "provenance": {
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Muscle Milk Pro Advanced Nutrition Protein Shake (chocolate, one 330 ml carton) found lead at 128 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 5½ servings a week. Muscle Milk did not respond to CR's requests for comment.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA enforcement reports dated 16 November 2016 hold 14 Class II records for ready-to-drink Muscle Milk shakes made by H.P. Hood, recalled for premature spoilage with swelled containers and foul odor. No later record was found. Searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Muscle+Milk\"+recalling_firm:\"Muscle+Milk\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Muscle Milk",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Muscle+Milk\"+recalling_firm:\"Muscle+Milk\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Milk protein",
    "Ready to drink"
   ],
   "description": "A widely sold ready-to-drink shake with a 2016 Class II recall and a lead result above CR's level of concern. NSF's register lists other Muscle Milk products but not this Pro Advanced shake, and no price was read.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 48
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "quest-protein-shake",
   "name": "Quest Protein Shake (ready to drink)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 52,
    "safety": 19,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Quest Nutrition Ready To Drink Protein Shake, Chocolate, 44 fl oz, 4 count, at $6.99 reduced from $10.49, with 30 g of protein per 325 ml shake. The score uses the $10.49 regular price, which is about $2.19 per 25 g of protein; the reduced price is about $1.46.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/quest-nutrition-ready-to-drink-protein-shake-chocolate/-/A-91125631",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Quest Protein Shake (chocolate, one 325 ml carton) found lead at 161 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 4⅓ servings a week. A Quest spokesperson told CR the levels show its food safety programmes are working.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA's enforcement reports, searched through openFDA on 29 September 2026 for Quest, hold Class II records from 28 January 2015 for QuestBar protein bars and a Class III record from 24 October 2018 for a Quest bar with undeclared almonds. No record for a Quest shake was found, so the shake scores 85.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Quest\"+recalling_firm:\"Quest\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/quest-nutrition-ready-to-drink-protein-shake-chocolate/-/A-91125631"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports, Quest",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Quest\"+recalling_firm:\"Quest\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Milk protein",
    "Ready to drink"
   ],
   "description": "A ready-to-drink shake sold at mass retail, with a lead result above CR's level of concern and FDA records only for the brand's bars.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 52,
    "cost": 52
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "owyn-pro-elite-shake",
   "name": "OWYN Pro Elite High Protein Shake (ready to drink)",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 67,
    "safety": 56,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists OWYN Pro Elite 32g Dairy Free Protein Shake, Chocolate, 11.15 fl oz, 12 pack, at $25.49, with 32 g of protein per shake, which is about $1.66 per 25 g of protein, the lowest of the shakes priced here.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/owyn-pro-elite-ready-to-drink-protein-shake-chocolate-11-5-fl-oz-12pk/-/A-94453380",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of OWYN Pro Elite High Protein Shake (chocolate, one 330 ml carton) found lead at 88 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, the lowest of the ready-to-drink shakes it tested, under Better Choices for Daily Consumption, with a limit of 1 serving a day. Owyn did not respond to CR's requests for comment.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for OWYN and Only What You Need found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/owyn-pro-elite-ready-to-drink-protein-shake-chocolate-11-5-fl-oz-12pk/-/A-94453380"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Ready to drink"
   ],
   "description": "A plant-based ready-to-drink shake with the lowest lead result among the shakes CR tested and the lowest price per 25 g of protein among the shakes priced here.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 70.5,
    "cost": 67
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org",
     "target.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 3
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "equip-prime-protein",
   "name": "Equip Foods Prime Protein (beef isolate)",
   "brand": "direct-to-consumer brand, beef protein powder",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "safety": 28,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of Equip Foods Prime Protein (chocolate, one 25.7 g scoop) found lead at 144 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 4¾ servings a week. CR reports that Equip Foods says it will give heavy metal test results to customers on request.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Equip Foods found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Beef protein",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "A beef protein isolate, the only beef-based powder in the roster. No price with a serving count could be read for it.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 56.5
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "kos-organic-plant-protein",
   "name": "KOS Organic Superfood Plant Protein",
   "brand": "",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "safety": 44,
    "health": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "safety": {
     "note": "Consumer Reports' October 2025 test of KOS Organic Superfood Plant Protein (vanilla, 37 g, two scoops) found lead at 112 percent of CR's level of concern per serving, under Okay to Eat Occasionally, with a limit of 6¼ servings a week. CR reports that KOS says it will give heavy metal test results to customers on request.",
     "source": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for KOS found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports lead test",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Plant-based",
    "Powder"
   ],
   "description": "A plant powder with a lead result slightly above CR's level of concern. The KOS page read for this decision sells a differently named 20 g product, so no price is scored.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 64.5
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "consumerreports.org"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "thorne-whey-protein-isolate",
   "name": "Thorne Whey Protein Isolate",
   "brand": "independent brand, whey isolate powder",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "health": 85,
    "certification": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Thorne found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "certification": {
     "note": "NSF's Certified for Sport register lists Thorne Whey Protein Isolate in chocolate (906 g package, 30.2 g scoop, 21 g protein) and vanilla (906 g package, 27.9 g scoop, 21 g protein). NSF says the programme verifies that products hold none of 290 banned substances, that the label matches the contents and that contaminants are not at unsafe levels. Searched 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1513727",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "NSF Certified for Sport listing",
     "url": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1513727"
    },
    {
     "label": "Thorne product page",
     "url": "https://www.thorne.com/products/dp/whey-protein-isolate-vanilla"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey isolate",
    "NSF Certified for Sport"
   ],
   "description": "A whey isolate on NSF's register with no FDA record found. Its own page prints 25 g of whey isolate per scoop where NSF's listing gives 21 g of protein, so no price per 25 g of protein is scored, and the page carries a California Proposition 65 warning about lead.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 85,
    "honesty": 85
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "nsfsport.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "transparent-labs-whey-isolate",
   "name": "Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate",
   "brand": "direct-to-consumer brand, whey isolate powder",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 59,
    "health": 85,
    "certification": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "transparentlabs.com lists Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate in the default size at $64.99 for a single purchase, 30 servings with 28 g of protein each, which is about $1.93 per 25 g of protein. The page links a heavy metals and microbial certificate of analysis for a lot.",
     "source": "https://transparentlabs.com/products/whey-protein-isolate",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "An openFDA search of FDA's food enforcement reports on 29 September 2026 for Transparent Labs found no record. One openFDA query for these brand names (Syntha, BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Truvani, Ritual, PlantFusion, Huel, OWYN, Only What You Need, Equip Foods, Thorne, Transparent Labs, KOS) plus Orgain as a control returned four records, all tied to Orgain, so it returned nothing under this brand name.",
     "source": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    },
    "certification": {
     "note": "NSF's Certified for Sport register lists Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate in 28 flavor listings; the chocolate hazelnut listing shows a 1104 g package, a 36.8 g scoop and 28 g of protein. Searched 29 September 2026.",
     "source": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1804288",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Transparent Labs product page",
     "url": "https://transparentlabs.com/products/whey-protein-isolate"
    },
    {
     "label": "NSF Certified for Sport listing",
     "url": "https://www.nsfsport.com/certified-products/listing-detail.php?id=1804288"
    },
    {
     "label": "FDA enforcement reports query, several brands",
     "url": "https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(product_description:\"Syntha\"+recalling_firm:\"Syntha\"+product_description:\"BSN\"+recalling_firm:\"BSN\"+product_description:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+recalling_firm:\"Clean+Simple+Eats\"+product_description:\"Truvani\"+recalling_firm:\"Truvani\"+product_description:\"Ritual\"+recalling_firm:\"Ritual\"+product_description:\"PlantFusion\"+recalling_firm:\"PlantFusion\"+product_description:\"Huel\"+recalling_firm:\"Huel\"+product_description:\"OWYN\"+recalling_firm:\"OWYN\"+product_description:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+recalling_firm:\"Only+What+You+Need\"+product_description:\"Equip+Foods\"+recalling_firm:\"Equip+Foods\"+product_description:\"Thorne\"+recalling_firm:\"Thorne\"+product_description:\"Transparent+Labs\"+recalling_firm:\"Transparent+Labs\"+product_description:\"KOS\"+recalling_firm:\"KOS\"+product_description:\"Orgain\"+recalling_firm:\"Orgain\")&limit=100"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Whey isolate",
    "NSF Certified for Sport",
    "Lot test results linked"
   ],
   "description": "A whey isolate on NSF's register that links a lab certificate from its product page. Consumer Reports tested this brand's mass gainer and not this isolate, so no lead score is given.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 85,
    "honesty": 85,
    "cost": 59
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 3,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "api.fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "api.fda.gov",
     "nsfsport.com",
     "transparentlabs.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "greek-yogurt-food-route",
   "name": "Plain nonfat Greek yogurt (food, no supplement)",
   "brand": "everyday food, no supplement",
   "allergens": [
    "milk"
   ],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "scores": {
    "economical": 88
   },
   "provenance": {
    "economical": {
     "note": "Target lists Good & Gather Greek Plain Nonfat Yogurt, 32 oz, at $3.29, about 5 servings of 3/4 cup with 18 g of protein each, which is about $0.91 per 25 g of protein.",
     "source": "https://www.target.com/p/greek-plain-nonfat-yogurt-32oz-good-38-gather-8482/-/A-78362087",
     "asof": "2026-09"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Target listing",
     "url": "https://www.target.com/p/greek-plain-nonfat-yogurt-32oz-good-38-gather-8482/-/A-78362087"
    },
    {
     "label": "Consumer Reports on protein and whole foods",
     "url": "https://www.consumerreports.org/lead/protein-powders-and-shakes-contain-high-levels-of-lead-a4206364640/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Food",
    "No supplement"
   ],
   "description": "The food route, priced well below every powder and shake. Consumer Reports' article says most adults can meet their protein needs from whole foods and names Greek yogurt among its alternatives, and it did not test yogurt for lead.",
   "valueSignature": {
    "cost": 88
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "target.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  }
 ]
}