{
 "meta": {
  "id": "cat-food",
  "label": "Cat food",
  "type": "Products",
  "primaryAxis": "health",
  "tradeoff": [
   "accessibility",
   "health"
  ],
  "tradeoffLabels": [
   "cheapest and easiest to find",
   "cleanest safety record"
  ],
  "source": "Conscious Consuming",
  "attribution": "Health and transparency scores are built only from FDA recall and safety-alert pages, company recall notices filed with FDA, CDC outbreak reporting, and independent food-safety journalism about a specific inspection or incident; where a search of FDA's own recall and safety-alert listings on the date shown found nothing for a brand, the note says exactly that, and that is an absence of a public record rather than a claim the brand is risk free. Price and availability come only from a company's own site or a retailer's own page describing its distribution, so most cells here are sparse: a fact that could not be verified from an acceptable source was left out rather than guessed. Transparency describes what a company's own materials or FDA inspection findings show about its manufacturing and sourcing. Reviewed 2026. Suggest corrections through Contribute.",
  "allergens": false,
  "presets": {
   "Balanced": {
    "w": {
     "accessibility": 3,
     "health": 3,
     "transparency": 2
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Cheapest and easiest to find": {
    "w": {
     "accessibility": 5,
     "health": 2,
     "transparency": 1
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Cleanest safety record": {
    "w": {
     "health": 5,
     "transparency": 2,
     "accessibility": 1
    },
    "x": []
   },
   "Most transparent": {
    "w": {
     "transparency": 5,
     "health": 3,
     "accessibility": 1
    },
    "x": []
   }
  },
  "n": 14,
  "valueSignatureProfile": {
   "entryCount": 14,
   "signedEntries": 14,
   "drawableEntries": 8,
   "minimumThemesForBloom": 2,
   "themeCounts": {
    "health": 12,
    "honesty": 6,
    "cost": 5
   }
  },
  "provenanceProfile": {
   "entryCount": 14,
   "singleSourceEntries": 10,
   "multiSourceEntries": 4,
   "noSourceEntries": 0,
   "noteOnlyEntries": 0,
   "averageSourceDomains": 1.36,
   "topPrimarySources": [
    {
     "label": "fda.gov",
     "entries": 5
    },
    {
     "label": "efoodalert.com",
     "entries": 3
    },
    {
     "label": "cbsnews.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "costco.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "foodsafetynews.com",
     "entries": 1
    },
    {
     "label": "royalcanin.com",
     "entries": 1
    }
   ]
  },
  "decision": {
   "category": "cat-food",
   "reads": {
    "text": "Compare cat food by body safety, everyday access, and disclosure.",
    "basis": [
     {
      "criterion": "health",
      "readsAs": "body safety"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "accessibility",
      "readsAs": "everyday access"
     },
     {
      "criterion": "transparency",
      "readsAs": "disclosure"
     }
    ],
    "signature": {
     "by": "Conscious Consuming",
     "on": "2026-07-15",
     "status": "approved-batch"
    },
    "receipt": {
     "dataset": "cat-food",
     "entryCount": 14,
     "criteria": [
      {
       "criterion": "health",
       "readsAs": "body safety",
       "known": 12,
       "minimum": 28,
       "maximum": 68,
       "spread": 40
      },
      {
       "criterion": "accessibility",
       "readsAs": "everyday access",
       "known": 5,
       "minimum": 30,
       "maximum": 75,
       "spread": 45
      },
      {
       "criterion": "transparency",
       "readsAs": "disclosure",
       "known": 6,
       "minimum": 30,
       "maximum": 85,
       "spread": 55
      }
     ]
    }
   },
   "axes": [
    {
     "id": "access-or-safety",
     "kind": "tradeoff",
     "label": "Access or safety record",
     "question": "Cheaper and easier to find, or a cleaner safety record?",
     "criteria": [
      "accessibility",
      "health"
     ],
     "poles": [
      "Easier to find",
      "Cleaner record"
     ],
     "default": 50
    },
    {
     "id": "transparency",
     "kind": "criterion",
     "label": "Disclosure",
     "question": "Does stronger disclosure matter more?",
     "criteria": [
      "transparency"
     ],
     "poles": [
      "Flexible",
      "Stronger disclosure"
     ],
     "default": 50
    }
   ],
   "budget": {
    "available": false,
    "mode": "none",
    "knownEntries": 0,
    "coverage": 0
   },
   "archetypes": [
    "best-for-most",
    "strictest-match"
   ],
   "page": {
    "stage": "approved-batch",
    "primaryRoute": true
   },
   "consumer": {
    "reads": "Round 8 approved category differences reads.",
    "axes": "Round 8 practical decision dials, with the S4 cost-or-values default where evidence permits.",
    "budget": "Round 8 honest budget eligibility, with S4 refusing to guess missing cost data.",
    "archetypes": "Round 8 computed answer slots matched to available category evidence.",
    "page": "Round 7 personal precedence extended in Round 9 to the shared decision page for every live category."
   }
  }
 },
 "criteria": [
  {
   "key": "accessibility",
   "label": "Price and availability",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  },
  {
   "key": "health",
   "label": "Recall and safety record",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  },
  {
   "key": "transparency",
   "label": "Ingredient and manufacturing transparency",
   "source": "curated",
   "tier": "assessed"
  }
 ],
 "products": [
  {
   "code": "purina-cat-chow",
   "name": "Purina Cat Chow",
   "brand": "Nestlé Purina",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Nestlé Purina's original dry cat food line, sold widely in US grocery and mass retail stores.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 63,
    "transparency": 74
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On December 26, 2025, third-party distributor Gold Star Distribution recalled all FDA-regulated products held at its Minneapolis warehouse, including Purina Cat Chow Complete dry cat food, after an FDA inspection found rodent droppings, rodent urine, and bird droppings in storage areas. The contamination was at the distributor's warehouse, not at a Purina manufacturing plant, and the notice said no illnesses had been reported to date.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/gold-star-distribution-inc-issues-recall-certain-fda-regulated-products-three-states-including-drugs",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Independent food-safety journalist Phyllis Entis reviewed an April 2023 FDA inspection of Nestlé Purina's Edmond, Oklahoma, plant, which the report says produces dry Cat Chow along with Friskies, Kit 'N Kaboodle, Kitten Chow, Purina ONE, and other dry lines. The inspector found no deviations or deficiencies and classified the visit 'No Action Indicated,' noting the plant tests finished product for Salmonella before release and requires corporate pre-approval of suppliers.",
     "source": "https://efoodalert.com/2024/04/04/fda-inspections-uncover-food-safety-issues-at-multiple-purina-plants/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.purina.com/cat-chow"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Budget",
    "Mass retail"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 63,
    "honesty": 74
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "efoodalert.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "efoodalert.com",
     "fda.gov"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "friskies",
   "name": "Friskies",
   "brand": "Nestlé Purina",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Nestlé Purina's budget wet and dry cat food line, sold widely in US grocery and mass retail stores.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 63,
    "transparency": 30
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On December 26, 2025, third-party distributor Gold Star Distribution recalled all FDA-regulated products held at its Minneapolis warehouse, including several Friskies varieties such as Shreds, Pate, Prime Filet, and Surfin' & Turfin' canned cat food, after an FDA inspection found rodent droppings, rodent urine, and bird droppings in storage areas. The notice said no illnesses had been reported to date.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/gold-star-distribution-inc-issues-recall-certain-fda-regulated-products-three-states-including-drugs",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Independent food-safety journalist Phyllis Entis reviewed a June 2023 FDA inspection of Nestlé Purina's Crete, Nebraska, plant, which cans Friskies along with Alpo, Purina ONE, and Pro Plan Veterinary Diets. The inspector traced an earlier mislabeling recall to a conveyor motor malfunction that let a batch of cat food and dog food comingle before the retort step, meaning some cans received the wrong thermal process, and found the plant relied only on magnets to catch foreign material and had problems controlling residual chlorine in its cooling water.",
     "source": "https://efoodalert.com/2024/04/04/fda-inspections-uncover-food-safety-issues-at-multiple-purina-plants/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.purina.com/friskies"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Budget",
    "Mass retail"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 63,
    "honesty": 30
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "efoodalert.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "efoodalert.com",
     "fda.gov"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "fancy-feast",
   "name": "Fancy Feast",
   "brand": "Nestlé Purina",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Nestlé Purina's mainstream wet cat food line, sold in small cans through US grocery and mass retail stores.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 63
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On December 26, 2025, third-party distributor Gold Star Distribution recalled all FDA-regulated products held at its Minneapolis warehouse, including Fancy Feast Creamy Delight Salmon, Medleys Florentine, and Gravy Lovers canned cat food, after an FDA inspection found rodent droppings, rodent urine, and bird droppings in storage areas. The notice said no illnesses had been reported to date.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/gold-star-distribution-inc-issues-recall-certain-fda-regulated-products-three-states-including-drugs",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.purina.com/fancy-feast"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Mainstream",
    "Mass retail"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 63
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "fda.gov",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "meow-mix",
   "name": "Meow Mix",
   "brand": "J.M. Smucker",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "J.M. Smucker's budget dry and wet cat food line, sold widely in US grocery and mass retail stores.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 65
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On April 9, 2021, The J.M. Smucker Co. recalled two lots of Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food 30 lb bags for potential Salmonella contamination. The products were sold at select Walmart stores in Illinois, Missouri, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah, Wisconsin, and Wyoming, and the company said it had received no reports of pet illness or adverse reaction.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/j-m-smucker-co-issues-limited-voluntary-recall-two-lots-meow-mixr-original-choice-dry-cat-food",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.meowmix.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Budget",
    "Mass retail"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 65
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "fda.gov",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "nine-lives",
   "name": "9Lives",
   "brand": "J.M. Smucker",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "J.M. Smucker's budget canned cat food line, one of the longest-running brands sold in US grocery and mass retail stores.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 50
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On December 7, 2018, The J.M. Smucker Co. recalled specific lots of 9Lives Protein Plus wet canned cat food, in Tuna & Chicken and Tuna & Liver varieties, for possible low levels of thiamine (vitamin B1). The products were distributed nationwide and the company said no illnesses related to the issue had been reported to date.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/jm-smucker-company-issues-voluntary-recall-specific-lots-9livesr-protein-plusr-wet-canned-cat-food",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.9lives.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Budget",
    "Mass retail"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 50
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "fda.gov",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "special-kitty",
   "name": "Special Kitty",
   "brand": "Walmart private label",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Walmart's private label cat food, sold only at Walmart stores and Walmart.com and made for Walmart by J.M. Smucker.",
   "scores": {
    "accessibility": 75,
    "health": 42
   },
   "provenance": {
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Walmart's own site groups Special Kitty under its 'Walmart Exclusive Pet Brands' category; the line is sold only at Walmart stores and Walmart.com, in dry, wet, and treat formats.",
     "source": "https://www.walmart.com/browse/pets/walmart-exclusive-pet-brands/5440_5185817",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "On December 5, 2019, The J.M. Smucker Co. recalled specific lots of Special Kitty Mixed Grill Dinner Pate and Special Kitty Surf & Turf Variety Pack wet canned cat food, distributed nationwide, for health concerns associated with ingredients the company said did not meet its quality and safety standards.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety-alerts/j-m-smucker-company-issues-voluntary-recall-specific-lots-special-kittyr-wet-canned-cat-food-due",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Retailer page",
     "url": "https://www.walmart.com/browse/pets/walmart-exclusive-pet-brands/5440_5185817"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Budget",
    "Walmart exclusive"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 42,
    "cost": 75
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "fda.gov",
     "walmart.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "iams-cat",
   "name": "Iams",
   "brand": "Mars Petcare",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "A Mars Petcare dry cat food sold widely in US grocery and mass retail stores.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 45
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On August 16, 2013, Procter & Gamble (Iams' owner at the time) recalled specific lots of Iams dry cat food, made during a 10-day window at a single manufacturing site, over Salmonella found in random testing. The lots represented about one-tenth of one percent of annual production and the company said no illnesses had been reported.",
     "source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/eukanuba-dog-food-iams-cat-food-recalled",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.iams.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Mid range",
    "Mass retail"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 45
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "cbsnews.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "taste-of-the-wild-cat",
   "name": "Taste of the Wild",
   "brand": "Diamond Pet Foods",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "A grain-free cat food line made by contract manufacturer Diamond Pet Foods, sold mainly through pet specialty and online retailers.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 28,
    "transparency": 35
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "Diamond Pet Foods recalled all package sizes and formulas of Taste of the Wild made between December 9, 2011 and April 7, 2012 after Salmonella Infantis traced to its Gaston, South Carolina, plant. CDC's May 11, 2012 update on the multistate outbreak confirmed at least 15 human infections across nine states, with five people hospitalized, plus two further cases reported by Canadian health authorities.",
     "source": "https://efoodalert.com/diamond-pet-foods-etc-recalls-2012/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "eFoodAlert's account of the 2012 recall lists Taste of the Wild alongside Diamond's own house brands and other third-party labels such as Kirkland Signature, Canidae, and Solid Gold, all made at the same Gaston, South Carolina, plant, showing Diamond manufactures for many competing labels rather than Taste of the Wild alone.",
     "source": "https://efoodalert.com/diamond-pet-foods-etc-recalls-2012/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.tasteofthewildpetfood.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Grain-free",
    "Pet specialty"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 28,
    "honesty": 35
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "efoodalert.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "kirkland-signature-cat",
   "name": "Kirkland Signature",
   "brand": "Costco private label",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Costco's private label cat food, made by contract manufacturer Diamond Pet Foods and sold to Costco members.",
   "scores": {
    "accessibility": 55,
    "health": 30
   },
   "provenance": {
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Costco's own 'About Kirkland Signature' page describes it as Costco's only private brand, sold exclusively through Costco's own warehouses and website; any Kirkland Signature product sold elsewhere was resold after first being bought at Costco, which requires a paid membership.",
     "source": "https://www.costco.com/f/-/about-kirkland-signature",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "Diamond Pet Foods' 2012 recall for Salmonella Infantis contamination at its Gaston, South Carolina, plant named Kirkland Signature Super Premium Maintenance Cat Chicken & Rice Formula and Kirkland Signature Super Premium Healthy Weight Cat Formula, both with best-before dates of December 9, 2012 through January 31, 2013. CDC confirmed at least 15 human infections across nine states in the outbreak, with five people hospitalized.",
     "source": "https://efoodalert.com/diamond-pet-foods-etc-recalls-2012/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Retailer page",
     "url": "https://www.costco.com/f/-/about-kirkland-signature"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Warehouse club",
    "Value"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 30,
    "cost": 55
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "costco.com",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "costco.com",
     "efoodalert.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 2
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "royal-canin-cat",
   "name": "Royal Canin",
   "brand": "Mars Petcare",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "A Mars Petcare brand built around breed, age, and health-condition specific formulas, sold only through pet specialty stores and veterinary clinics.",
   "scores": {
    "accessibility": 40
   },
   "provenance": {
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Royal Canin's own FAQ says its retail products cannot be bought directly from its facilities and are sold exclusively through pet specialty stores, while its Veterinary Exclusive formulas, including its feline renal and urinary diets, are only available by prescription through vet clinics; it is not sold in grocery stores.",
     "source": "https://www.royalcanin.com/ca/about-us/faqs",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.royalcanin.com/us"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Vet exclusive",
    "Breed specific"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "cost": 40
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "royalcanin.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 0,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "hills-science-diet-cat",
   "name": "Hill's Science Diet",
   "brand": "Colgate-Palmolive",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Colgate-Palmolive's veterinary linked cat food brand, sold mainly through pet specialty stores, vet clinics, and online.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 68,
    "transparency": 70
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "FDA's own notice about Hill's 2019 recall for excess vitamin D states that 'the recall is only for canned dog food and does not affect canned cat food, dry food (kibble), or treats.' A search of FDA's recalls, market withdrawals, and safety alerts listings on this date found no separate cat-food-specific recall for Hill's Science Diet or Prescription Diet; this is an absence of a public record, not independent proof the food carries no risk.",
     "source": "https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/outbreaks-and-advisories/fda-alerts-pet-owners-and-veterinarians-about-potentially-toxic-levels-vitamin-d-33-varieties-hills",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Hill's own site says it manufactures its recipes in Colgate-Palmolive owned and operated facilities and that its PhD nutritionists and veterinarians test recipes on site, with more than 900 dogs and cats involved in confirming final products before they ship; the page does not separate this claim by species.",
     "source": "https://www.hillspet.com/about-us/sustainability",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.hillspet.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Vet recommended",
    "Pet specialty"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 68,
    "honesty": 70
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 2,
    "singleSource": false,
    "primarySource": "fda.gov",
    "sourceLabels": [
     "fda.gov",
     "hillspet.com"
    ],
    "independentSourceCount": 1,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "wellness-cat-food",
   "name": "Wellness",
   "brand": "WellPet",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "WellPet's natural-positioned canned cat food line, sold through pet specialty and online retailers.",
   "scores": {
    "health": 48
   },
   "provenance": {
    "health": {
     "note": "On February 28, 2011, WellPet recalled all flavors and sizes of Wellness Canned Cat Food with best-by dates from April 14 through September 30, 2013, plus Wellness Canned Cat Food Chicken & Herring with two November 2013 best-by dates, after independent testing conducted with FDA in response to a consumer complaint found low levels of thiamine (vitamin B1). An estimated 21.6 million cans were affected.",
     "source": "https://www.foodsafetynews.com/2011/03/cat-food-recalled-for-lack-of-thiamine/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.wellnesspetfood.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Natural",
    "Pet specialty"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 48
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 1,
    "sourcedFactCount": 1,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "foodsafetynews.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "smalls",
   "name": "Smalls",
   "brand": "Smalls",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "A fresh, human-grade cat food delivered by subscription, formulated with veterinary nutritionists and shipped refrigerated.",
   "scores": {
    "accessibility": 30,
    "transparency": 60
   },
   "provenance": {
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Smalls' own site describes an online 'build your cat's fresh plan' subscription with home delivery and free shipping; the food is not sold in stores and needs to go in the fridge or freezer as soon as it arrives.",
     "source": "https://www.smalls.com/",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "Smalls' own site says its recipes are 'formulated with veterinary nutritionists and certified complete and balanced for every life stage' and describes the food as gently cooked from real, whole ingredients with no preservatives or fillers; the page does not name the manufacturing facility.",
     "source": "https://www.smalls.com/",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "Website",
     "url": "https://www.smalls.com/"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Fresh",
    "Subscription"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "honesty": 60,
    "cost": 30
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 2,
    "sourcedFactCount": 2,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "smalls.com",
    "independentSourceCount": 0,
    "ownSiteCited": true
   }
  },
  {
   "code": "home-cooked-vet-formulated-cat",
   "name": "Home-cooked, vet-formulated diet",
   "brand": "not a manufactured product",
   "allergens": [],
   "allergensDeclared": false,
   "description": "Cooking a complete and balanced diet at home from ordinary grocery ingredients, using a recipe from a board certified veterinary nutritionist rather than buying a manufactured food.",
   "scores": {
    "accessibility": 55,
    "health": 38,
    "transparency": 85
   },
   "provenance": {
    "accessibility": {
     "note": "Home-cooked food uses ordinary grocery ingredients rather than depending on one manufacturer or retailer, so it can be made anywhere there is a kitchen and a grocery store. UC Davis researchers who evaluated 114 published cat food recipes found only 94 had enough detail for nutritional analysis, and cooking a diet daily takes far more time than opening a can or bag.",
     "source": "https://www.ucdavis.edu/curiosity/homemade-cat-food-diets-could-be-risky",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "health": {
     "note": "UC Davis researchers analyzed the 94 published homemade cat food recipes with enough detail to test and found that none met the National Research Council's recommended allowances for every essential nutrient for adult cats; many fell short on up to 19 nutrients, and several provided less than half the recommended amount of choline, iron, zinc, thiamin, vitamin E, or manganese. Seven percent of all 114 recipes called for a potentially toxic ingredient such as garlic, onion, or leek. Only five recipes, all written by veterinarians, came within one nutrient of meeting every requirement.",
     "source": "https://www.ucdavis.edu/curiosity/homemade-cat-food-diets-could-be-risky",
     "asof": "2026"
    },
    "transparency": {
     "note": "A home-cooked diet has no manufacturer between the ingredients and the bowl, so the cook buys and sees every ingredient directly. UC Davis's review found that turning this into a nutritionally complete diet in practice requires the kind of formulation that, in its sample, only recipes written by veterinarians came close to delivering.",
     "source": "https://www.ucdavis.edu/curiosity/homemade-cat-food-diets-could-be-risky",
     "asof": "2026"
    }
   },
   "links": [
    {
     "label": "UC Davis study summary",
     "url": "https://www.ucdavis.edu/curiosity/homemade-cat-food-diets-could-be-risky"
    }
   ],
   "region": [
    "US"
   ],
   "focuses": [
    "Not a purchase",
    "Requires a vet nutritionist recipe"
   ],
   "valueSignature": {
    "health": 38,
    "honesty": 85,
    "cost": 55
   },
   "provenanceSummary": {
    "factCount": 3,
    "sourcedFactCount": 3,
    "sourceDomainCount": 1,
    "singleSource": true,
    "primarySource": "ucdavis.edu",
    "independentSourceCount": 1
   }
  }
 ]
}